For those who aren’t aware this is more-or-less a response to the rise of prominent accounts on X leading the charge on getting people fired from their jobs for statements about the attempted assassination of ex-president and presidential candidate Trump.
As of today, if you search “libs of tiktok” on X and browse the top posts you’ll find many such examples, including a termination from home depot. [archive link] This demonstrates that not only is this popular, but it’s widely promoted.
I posted a note on the Fediverse today, which summarizes my position against this kind of behavior. As somebody who was terminated for far less, I’ll admit it pains me to have to stick up for people who likely would do the same to me again.
Forming mobs hunting people down to get them fired for legally protected speech is wrong. In my opinion, there should be stronger labor protections for speech across the board because of nonsense like this.
Despite the recent rise of people on the right going after people for wishing the assassination succeeded, the left absolutely has to own that they’ve spent over a decade normalizing and defending this nonsense. It is no surprize at all, and was predicted from the very beginning that it would eventually lead to this.
My standard for culture war bullshit is that target selection matters. I’m sorry, but I don’t think somebody wishing the president died is actually that big a deal. I’m pretty sure a majority of people are guilty of this for at least one head of state in their lives. If these were people advocating for criminal behavior (or behavior that should be criminal) I would feel differently, but it never has been.
The truth is, I also blame employers for this. It’s all too easy to throw the employee under the bus to avoid a tiny bit of bad PR. I think if there was ever a purpose for ‘sensitivity training’ it should be used for situations like this. I think it shows a lack of respect for your workers if you’ll let them go over such a tiny thing without even attempting to address the root issue.
If people actually want free speech and meritocracy, we’re going to need institutions that are actually more resilient to human failings, rather than pretending we can purge them in totality. Again, this is something I blame the left for a great deal because progressives were perfectly fine with shaping institutions to their values when it suited them. Now the shoe is on the other foot and ordinary people are yet again being torched to establish a new order of political correctness.
This is the bed that was made, I’d like us to build a different one but for now this seems to be the one we’re lying in for the time being.
Despite my frustration with those engaging in this, you can see that I actually blame so-called “progressives” a great deal for this. They have a long history not only initiating this behavior, but also normalizing and excusing it. This is exactly what “freedom of speech isn’t freedom from consequences” looks like at the start.
Some can argue this is a normal ‘swinging of the pendulum’ but the truth is that our actions have consequences that do matter. Retaliation and revenge only makes it harder and harder to actually bring people to admit their faults and change for the better.
I pray that those pushing back against the rallying cries to mercilessly punish ordinary people help others choose to save such harsh tactics for truly important concerns, rather than petty nonsense.
“But I HAVE to punish my enemies or things will just get worse!”
It’s funny how common this sentiment is despite it being demonstrably false in the moment.
If that was true why wasn’t left-wing cancel culture able to prevent this moment?
Things are getting worse because people don’t have their heads in the game. That Libs of Tiktok post over a home depot employee got much more attention than many pressing (but complicated) issues. The moment you seriously try tackling a real problem you’ll encounter defeatists who argue resolving it is impossible or just simply too hard to bother.
You should pray for your enemies, but also remember a random cashier in an entirely different region from you isn’t even your enemy. They’re essentially a figment of your imagination put there by those who want to profit of rage-bait and an endless cycle of disrespect. In my opinion, those people are your actual enemies, but the good news is that you can resolve it by simply no longer giving them your attention.